Peer Review Process
IJISEA (International Journal for Interdisciplinary Sciences and Engineering Applications)
follows a rigorous and transparent peer review process to ensure the publication of high-quality,
original, and academically significant research articles.
The peer review process plays a vital role in maintaining the scientific integrity, credibility,
and academic standards of the journal. All submitted manuscripts are evaluated by qualified reviewers
or subject experts with relevant academic and research expertise.
1. Initial Manuscript Screening
After manuscript submission, the editorial office conducts an initial screening to verify the manuscript’s
scope relevance, formatting requirements, originality, language quality, and compliance with journal policies.
2. Plagiarism and Ethical Verification
The manuscript may undergo plagiarism detection and ethical evaluation to ensure originality and adherence
to publication ethics and academic integrity standards.
3. Reviewer Assignment
Eligible manuscripts are assigned to independent reviewers or editorial board experts based on the subject area,
research specialization, and technical expertise required for evaluation.
4. Review Evaluation
Reviewers assess the manuscript on various criteria including originality, research methodology, technical accuracy,
clarity of presentation, significance of findings, literature review, references, and overall contribution to the field.
5. Reviewer Recommendations
Based on their evaluation, reviewers may recommend one of the following decisions:
• Accept without changes.
• Accept with minor revisions.
• Resubmit after major revisions.
• Reject the manuscript.
Reviewers may also provide constructive comments and suggestions to help authors improve the quality of their manuscript.
6. Editorial Decision
The editorial board carefully reviews reviewer comments and recommendations before making the final editorial decision.
The corresponding author is informed about the review outcome along with reviewer feedback.
7. Author Revision
If revisions are requested, authors must revise the manuscript accordingly and submit a corrected version
along with responses addressing reviewer comments within the specified time period.
8. Final Acceptance and Publication
After successful revision and final editorial approval, the manuscript is accepted for publication and proceeds
to formatting, proofreading, DOI assignment, and online publication.
Confidentiality and Fairness
All manuscripts and reviewer communications are treated confidentially. The journal ensures an unbiased, fair,
and objective review process without discrimination based on nationality, gender, institutional affiliation,
or personal beliefs.
IJISEA is committed to maintaining a professional and ethical peer review system that promotes academic excellence,
research integrity, and scholarly quality.
